More Changes Coming to SABS in June 2016

4 September 15, 2015 at 3:43 pm by

Published in the K-W OIAA September 2015 Bulletin by Dan Strigberger

iStock_000020922298_SmallOn August 26, 2015, the Ontario Legislature filed Bill 251/15, which amends the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule in a number of remarkable ways. For the most part, the amendments apply only to policies issued or renewed on or after June 1, 2016. Existing contracts will remain subject to the current limits until the contract is terminated or renewed.

The most notable/talked about changes are to the catastrophic impairment definitions, but there are also significant changes to the non-earner benefits and med/rehab benefits available under the policy. What follows is a brief overview of the notable changes and the possible implications the accident benefits and tort industries faces with them.

Catastrophic Impairment

The catastrophic impairment definition post June 1, 2016 includes new and/or updated definitions and criteria for traumatic brain injuries for adults and children. The new definition adopts a number of medical tools to categorize these impairments, such as reference to a (bedside) text called “Structured Interviews for the Glasgow Outcome Scale and the Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale: Guidelines for Their Use, Journal of Neurotrauma, Volume 15”. The often-controversial and highly problematic Glasgow Coma Scale category is removed.

The new definition also updates criteria for amputations, ambulatory mobility, loss of vision, and mental and behavioural impairments. Of note, Pastore has been overruled: Future catastrophic status for pure mental and behavioural disorders will require marked impairment in three of four aspects of function, or extreme impairment in one aspect, and the person must be precluded from useful function.

Finally, the Desbiens / Kusnierz methods of “combining” physical and mental impairments now must be done with the American Medical Association’s Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 6th edition (as opposed to the 4th edition). The 6th edition provides a specific methodology for assigning a Whole Person Impairment (WPI) to certain mental and behavioural conditions, which the Legislature has adopted for use in conjunction with the 4th edition’s system for rating other impairments.

Catastrophic Limits

For catastrophic impairment claims, a new combined med/rehab and attendant care benefit of $1 million is available. This reduces the potential amount of recovery under the policy significantly from $1 million for med/rehab and $1 million for attendant care.

Non-Earner Benefits

Under the existing SABS, the non-earner benefits are paid after a six-month waiting period after the accident (onset of disability), up to two years post-accident at a rate of $185/week. If the person continues to meet the disability test after two years, the benefit amount increases to $320/week. Further, the benefit is available to a claimant who is 16 years of age or older.

As of June 1, 2016, the six-month waiting period is replaced by a four-week waiting period, but the benefit is no longer payable after two-years. Therefore, the $320/week benefit is eliminated and the insurer’s exposure stops at the two-year mark. Finally, the benefit is not payable to anyone who is under 18 years old.

Medical / Rehab and Attendant Care Benefits

The new changes significantly water down the non-catastrophic med/rehab and attendant care benefits. A new standard benefit that combines med/rehab and attendant care limits these claims to $65,000 (instead of $50,000 for med/rehab and $36,000 for attendant care).

Most importantly, the non-catastrophic med/rehab benefits are no longer available after five years post accident (instead of 10 years). Of course this change may not make much difference in the long term considering how difficult it can (or should) be to make $50,000 last over the course of 10 years. Nevertheless, the insurer’s exposure post accident for these benefits will stop after five years. The new duration does not apply to children under 18 at the time of the accident.

Optional Benefits for Med/Rehab and Attendant Care

The current optional $100,000 non-catastrophic med/rehab and $72,000 attendant care benefit have been eliminated. Instead, policyholders can purchase a new combined optional med/rehab and attendant care benefit of $130,000, which doubles the $65,000 standard limit for these benefits. They can also purchase the existing optional $1 million combined med/rehab and attendant care benefit that is available currently.

For catastrophic impairments, a new optional benefit of up to an additional $1 million for med/rehab and attendant care will be available. This optional benefit essentially would restore the catastrophic limits to the default catastrophic limits available today (although the med/rehab benefits would be combined with the attendant care benefits up to $2 million).

Other Changes – Attendant Care

The amendments have tweaked the attendant care benefit claim by confining entitlement to actual losses when an attendant care provider performs the services at a cost that is less than the actual amount stipulated on the Form 1 (“Assessment of Attendant Care Needs”).

Implications Going Forward

The new changes present a number of challenges for insurers and claimants alike. Insurance adjusters will have to wrap their heads around the several new tools/texts that have been inserted in the new catastrophic definition, which could make responding to these claims difficult for the next while.

Tort adjusters should also expect to see more claims with higher exposures now that the standard and catastrophic med/rehab limits have been significantly reduced. Direct writers/brokers should consider advising their customers to purchase enough liability coverage going forward.

The new amendments are available on e-laws:

Note: By submitting your comments you acknowledge that insBlogs has the right to reproduce, broadcast and publicize those comments or any part thereof in any manner whatsoever. Please note that due to the volume of e-mails we receive, not all comments will be published and those that are published will not be edited. However, all will be carefully read, considered and appreciated.

4 Comments » for More Changes Coming to SABS in June 2016
  1. Pauline Shenton says:

    Concise commentary on complicated issues. Thank you.

  2. Rick Howard says:

    The “old” Non-Earner Benefit” only increased to $320 per week if the applicant qualified for this benefit as a full-time student or completed their education less than one year before the accident and was neither employed or self-employed after completing their education and before the accident, in a capacity that reflected their education and training. Not all applicants non-earner benefit would be increased to $320 per week after having received it for 104 weeks and remained entitled to the benefit.

  3. The most significant change will be to medical and rehabilitation care, which will be combined with attendant care as a single benefit for both catastrophic and non-catastrophic claims. This severely limits the coverage available to those with serious injuries.

    • Rick Howard says:

      I do not disagree with you in that regard. Just wanted to point out the issue related to payment of an increased non-earner benefit after the applicant has received it for 104 weeks. Not all applicants non-earner benefit automatically increased to $320 per week after 104 weeks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *